Tanglewood in Shingleton
Flavors: Beef
Huge, not portable, mushy interior, needs salt/herbs
Crust was tasty
Grade: C/C-
Gram's in Escanaba
Flavors: Beef and potato, Beef and potato and rutabaga
Small cubes, tender and not overdone, portable, flavor wasn't as good as Jack's
Crust was tender, pretty soft
Grade: B/B+
Jack's fresh market in Manistique
Flavors: Veggie, Beef and mushroom, Beef and potato
Better flavor
Chunks were larger than Gram's, interior slightly more mushy than Gram's
Crust was fine, slightly crispier than Gram's
Grade: B+/A-
Muldoon's in Munising
Flavors: Beef
Most portable
Decent flavor
Larger chunks but not too mushy
Crust was fine
Grade: B/B+
Lawry's in Marquette
Flavors: Garden medley
Broccoli tasted weird in it (maybe some cheese)
Not the most flavorful but not the least
Most portable so far
Grade: B-
Amy J's Pasties
Flavors: Beef, Veggie
General notes
Best crust held together (very portable)
Sliced/scalloped fillings versus cubed
Slightly too big
Needed a bit more flavor
Beef-more flavorful than veggie
Grade: A-